He will find a chart or study which backs his views, and try to trump other views. Or post something, then say “I didn’t say that, it was a quote”. Where he spends his time there are many, many spurious studies which back his political views. Common sense does not count. For instance, what is the outcome of the increasing disparity of wealth, the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer? That’s a real “duh”, but he can’t figure it out. Common sense.

He once told me he doesn’t read history because he “doesn’t need anyone to tell me how to think”.

Don’t try to nail him down. He won’t/can’t take responsibility for his views because they all originated with others.

2. He says withholding a budget till concessions are made is unacceptable.

3. Both propositions are the same.

4. He is a hypocrite.

Fine (though I think #3 needs a bit of establishment, I won’t quibble). However, you’ve been making a list of Bart Simpson excuses supporting the budget hostage stance. And you have a long-standing view that strikes are bad. So, congrats: you are as much a hypocrite as he, and proven so by your own arguement. (assuming that #3 stands as is)